Accidentally cucked a guy.

Back in college, I had a good thing going with a friend with benefits. The first time we met, we were randomly on a train going back to school one day and saw we were both wearing our University shirts. I’m pretty shy, but she came right over and started talking to me. After we got off the train, a few weeks went by and we happened to see each other at a party. We were both pretty drunk, and I have no idea why, but I was lamenting about my ex and showed this girl some nudes I still had of her. She commented that she was hot/had really nice tits (she did), and that she would have fucked her. In my drunken confidence, I said we should try to find a girl and we could both fuck her together. She was 100% on board, and we went around the party asking other ladies if they wanted to have a threesome. No one took us up on our offer (lol), so we ended up just fucking each other that night. This turned into a FWB thing, and we didn’t try to actively seek another threesome. But sometimes things have a way of happening anyway.

We were going at it one night, when her roommate came back to their dorm with a guy. We had no shame and just said hi as we were both naked and I was inside her. Her roommate laughed and cheered us on, but the guy just kinda awkwardly stood there. We joked and said “come join us!”, and her roommate without a beat just said ok, and stripped down. I got off the bed, and the roommate climbed right in with my friend. They started by just kissing and touching each others tits as I stood next to the guy (he was clothed, I was naked). Now I cheered them on, and joked that they should 69. To my surprise and pleasure, they actually did. I watched with wide eyes as they ate each other out, and the guy again just nervously chuckled as I cheered. After a few mins, I got right in there and started kissing them both. The roommate then took me by the hand over to her bed and told me to fuck her.

Now, my understanding was that I’d fuck the roommate, and this guy would fuck my friend. I didn’t look back and went right at it with the roommate. As I started to climax, I asked her where she wanted me to cum. She said in her mouth, so that’s exactly what I did. Once the deed was done, we turned and saw the guy still clothed and my friend awkwardly laying there naked. Me and the roommate looked at them confusedly, and the guy had a look of humiliation and anger. He began shouting at the roommate saying “what the fuck! You just fucked that guy?! We’re supposed to be together!! I want to fuck you, not her!” A feeling of dread came over me as I thought he was going to beat my ass, but it was actually worse – he started apologizing to ME, saying he was sorry for yelling at me and that it’s not my fault, and that we’re cool…after I just fucked his girlfriend and came in her mouth…I ended up moving to the bed with my friend, and we huddled together naked, scared as the roommate and her guy screamed at each other. He stormed out and the roommate got dressed and followed. My friend and I laughed about how incredibly awkward that was, and then fucked again to end the night.

So yeah all in all, pretty great success for me and my friend, but mega awkward accidental cuckholdery.