The time a hot redhead insisted I buttfuck her…

Like most of the stories I’ve posted, this one takes place in my early 20s while at college and heavily involved in my town’s punk/alternative music scene. One night after a show, we had called in a few pizzas and were waiting outside to pick them up and head to someone’s house to eat before we called it a night. We were all pretty tired and sweaty, having gotten a good workout between singalongs, catching ​stage divers, and dodging elbows in/near the pit. There was a super cute chick hanging out with our group that I had met in passing, but didn’t know very well. As we were waiting, she kept seeming to work her way to whatever conversation I was in, until finally it was just the two of us.

She was a bit shorter than me, with elbow length red hair she usually kept up in a messy bun (the art student type, not the suburban mom type), bright green eyes, full lips she usually tinted a light pink, fairly pale skin, and a lot of freckles. She had wide hips, a big ass, and C cup tits that she usually kept hidden under a baggy hoodie or coat when we first met. Once she was away from her small home town and getting more comfortable in college, she started to show her frame a bit more at times. She also had a song lyric tattooed along her collarbones (common for the era), stretched earlobe piercings, and snake bite lower lip piercings.

We talked about the show and how things had gone, then she asked if I had her phone number. I replied that I didn’t, so we exchanged numbers, me thinking initially it was in case we needed to contact for something mundane. She stood next to me through a few more conversations, then when it was a quiet moment while I had my hands in my hoodie pocket, she reached one arm through between my elbow and my body, then clasped her hands and said “I think we’re going to be great friends.”

I was a bit taken back, since I had received some interest in this way, but only from people I knew much better than her. I didn’t pull away, but felt a bit awkward in the moment. She let go after a minute or so, smiled at me, then went back over to her best friend while I talked to another person. I noticed she and her roommate looking my way and giggling a bit here and there. I knew her roommate much better than her, and also knew she had heard stories and seen a few photos from a previous sexual partner of mine, and knew I had a fairly large penis. 7″x5.25″ isn’t huge, but definitely one that the ladies talked about.

Once we got to a nearby house and settled in to eat, I noticed her rommate kept calling her by the nickname “Meat.” Eventually, I asked about her nickname, and if she preferred it over her real name. They both smirked a bit, said it was sort of a joke nickname because she was vegetarian, and that I could call her whatever I felt comfortable with. A bit later, her rommate quietly asked if I wanted to know how she really got the nickname. I said sure, thinking there was maybe a funny story to go with it. All she told me was ​”she loves taking dick” and walked away.

The night went on without much of note, and we all headed off to get some sleep before class/work the next day. 2 nights later, she texted me and we had a bit of a short convo​. She eventually asked me if our mutual friend had told me a different meaning for her nickname, and I said yes. She asked what it was, and I said she had given a sexual meaning to it. She asked “did she say I like dick?”, to which I said yes. She sent a few acronyms and LOLs before saying that she made that up. Then immediately clarified that it wasn’t how she got the nickname, but admitted her friend wasn’t wrong about liking dick. She then asked if I really wanted to know how she got the nickname. I said “of course,” and she replied by saying “she came up with it the first time she saw this,” followed by a close up photo of her vagina.

She had parted it slightly, glistening and pink. She had a puffy mons and a bit of a longer labia. I inspected the photo momentarily, then replied “that would explain it,” then asked “the first time she saw it?” She let me know that in their 2 years of friendship, they had hooked up a few times when horny and single. I joked back and said I’d appreciate an invite the next time. She said she’d invite me over right then, but first she wanted to know of something she heard about me was true. Playing a bit of a game with her, I feigned ignorance and asked what that could be. She then asked “is it true you have a big cock.” I said “it depends on how you define big,” and “based on your size, I bet both of your hands, plus enough for you to still suck.”

I had never had this much lead in to a hook up, since they had all previously been proposed in the moment by my sexual partners. I was really enjoying the teasing and back and forth. She then said “well, I showed you mine… let’s see yours.” I sent one where it was laying up my stomach, tip almost reaching my belly button (that photo is pinned in my profile, by the way). After a short pause in her messages, she said “you need to come over here and fuck me right now.” I said I’d be right over.

When I got there, her roommate let me in and said “She’s waiting for you down the hall.” I headed down until I came to a room with a door slightly ajar, some quiet music playing, and dimmed lights. She definitely set a tone for the meet up. I asked if I could come in, then entered the room to see her in a black bra than showed most of her tits, and a pair of very cheeky lace panties. I walked to her bed, she grabbed my waistband to undo the button, then unzipped me while looking up and telling me “I needed to find out for myself.” I told her I respected her not wasting any time. My pants were now pulled down to mid thigh, and she was rubbing my dick through my underwear. I was fully hard almost immediately, watching her tits jiggle while she stared at my growing cock. I eventually took it out and started to rub it on her face. She took me in her mouth and began sucking and slurping to her heart’s content, while removing her bra. She did wind up holding it with both hands, still able to swirl her tongue around the tip while sucking the last inch or a bit more, then smiled at me and said “you’re were right.”

She repositioned onto her back so I could eat her out, and I had her clutching the sheets, grabbing my hair, and gasping for breath in no time. She made a point to reach down to rub some of her prolific pussy juices on her asshole, then put a hand on my cheek and said “please, please, just buttfuck me.” I had been asked for this a few times prior, but never as a first meeting request. And definitely not until we had vaginal intercourse first. She said “you’re the exact size I want in my asshole, just fuck my ass, please.”​ I rose up from eating her out, kissed her on the cheek, and told her “Of course.” We started making out while I fingered her ass and she jerked me off. I got 2, then 3 fingers inside her ass. The entire time, her pussy was a waterfall, with juices running down into her ass to help me lubricate the way. She did reach into her headboard shelf to pass me a bottle of lube, then asked me to start fucking her. I squeezed a bit of lube into my fingers to rub into her, then coated my cock thoroughly. As I did this, she reached into the headboard again and grabbed a small vibrator, pressing it to her clit while I began to slowly enter her asshole.

We reapplied lube as needed to make proper penetration comfortable for her, until I was balls deep in her ass. She started to alternate the vibrator between her clit and fucking her pussy with it. I asked her if I could take it from her at one point, then made eye contact and slowly pretended I was blowing the vibrator, making a show of being silly while I licked the surface clean. She laughed a bit in while panting, and I told her I just needed to taste her some more. We then pressed it hard into her clit and held it there while I fucked her deep and fast.

Her moans got louder, eventually turning into yells and screams, until she went a bit rigid, squeezed even tighter on my dick and had a loud, shaking orgasm. I kept fucking her asshole, and she kept rattling the windows with her sounds. She relaxed a bit,then asked if I had cum yet. I said not yet, them she told me “cum on my face.” I pulled out, and almost immediately coated her face. I thankfully missed her eyes, because she maintained eye contact the whole time, mouth open and tongue out. She sucked the last few drops out while my legs shook, then surprised me by calling her roommate, and asked her to bring her camera. She walked down the hall and opened the door to see my cock in her mouth, with her Polaroid in hand. She snapped 3 photos, then said it sounded like we had a lot of fun. We laughed a breathless laugh and said we had.

I got dressed, while she just put her panties with no bra, then took me to the living room to check out the pictures her roommate took. We each picked one, and she wrote the date on the back and drew a heart on the front. We kissed again while her roommate watched and smiled, then offered me another photo before I left. It was a POV Polaroid of her eating out Meat, saying “that’s how she really got the nickname.” She then complimented my dick, saying it looked better in person, and told me to come back again soon to spend some time. And for the next few months, I collected a few more Polaroids, and eventually got one of both of them sucking my dick. But, that’s a story for another time.