Mistaken Identity

My 23yr old step daughter, Taylor, had her good friend Brooke, also 23, over Friday evening to the house to let loose from a long week. The drinks came quickly and often. My wife decided she wanted to join them drinking so I decided to let the ladies have fun and stay away. I retreated to my man cave.

Taylor and Brooke are both very good looking and sexy. I’ve had the taboo fantasy of fucking my stepdaughter but never acted on it. Taylor does tease me by what she wears around the house and has been flirty but has a boyfriend with the same name as me, Mike.

Brooke, on the other hand, is more sexual with me. We sext often and even video chat to get each other off. She won’t go any farther because she also has a boyfriend, John.

Drinking gets Brooke horny so during the evening, she would sext with me and sent a few pics of her in our bathroom with just a t-shirt, no bra, and panties on. She has some amazing D cup boobs and a nice ass. I tried to get her into my man cave but she’d always tell me she has a boyfriend.

Eventually, my wife came into my mancave and told me she was going to bed and was definitely drunk so no sex with her. I waited about 30 minutes so she would pass out before I went to bed but I went to get a drink first.

It was dark in the living room but there was enough light coming from the kitchen that I could see Brooke asleep on the couch. Her back was towards me and her shirt was up and I could see she was wearing a thong. I had never seen her naked in person so I moved closer to get a better look.

Her ass looked good and against my better judgment, I began to feel her ass. She didn’t move so I decided to feel up her shirt. When I found her nipples, Brooke let out a little moan and said, “that feels good John. Just fuck me now.”

She thought I was her boyfriend. I hesitated for a second but my dick took over my thoughts.

I quickly pulled my shorts off and moved Brooke’s thong to the side. I gave her pussy a quick sniff before rubbing my cock on her bald pussy.

“Let me get on my knees and don’t forget the condom.”

She moved that her knees were on the floor but her upper body was still on the couch. I don’t need condoms. I got a vasectomy several years ago so I chanced it and pushed my bare cock inside her.

“Damn John, you must be excited. You feel so thick. Are you using a different brand of condom?”

I didn’t say anything, I just started to fuck her. Her young pussy is definitely tighter than my wife’s and I knew I wouldn’t last long so I was going slow. Brooke started pushing back into me.

“What are you doing John? Fuck me hard like it like it.”

She raised her upper body up and told me to pinch her nipples. I then reached under her shirt and began to pinch her nipples while she backed into me hard. I tried but I couldn’t hold on and I unloaded inside Brooke. She screamed out when I came.

“What the fuck John? Did you just cum in me? Did the condom break? You know I’m not on birth control.”

I pulled Brooke up to my chest and growled into her ear.

“I just fucked you raw and came inside you and I’m not John.”

I heard a gasp but it wasn’t from Brooke. It came from behind us. I turned and saw someone leaving the room.