My girlfriend's best friend

My name is Jonathan and I am a 24 years old man living by myself in an apartment in New York City. I have a girlfriend whose name is Pat, and we met while in college. I worked as a photographer for magazines, and she was a dentist. We have been dating for around a year and half now, and we’re very happy in our relationship. Sex with Pat is amazing, she really is a freak and pleases me in every position I ask her to make. We have even had our share of risky sex, fucking in dressing rooms at malls and in parties. Our relationship was very nice.

However, Pat had a friend. Her best friend. Her name was Lucy, and she was a very hot girl. Long brown hair, gray eyes, a figure like an hourglass, plump lips and a very charming attitude. She was slightly flirty around me, even more so whenever Pat was not around. I had the feeling she wanted to start something, but my own fear did not let me make any moves. What if Pat and her were planning something, to find how loyal I could be? I did not want to take risks.

However, Lucy also had a boyfriend, and I seemed no reason for her to want to cheat on him. He seems to be the kind of guy that would be with a girl like her, unlike me. Average size, tan skin, green eyes, not very muscular… I was average at best. Aside from all that, I did not think that Lucy would go as far as to betray Pat by hitting on her boyfriend, anyway.

Friday night, Pat’s apartment. We’re making out on her couch, slightly drunk. We had just arrived from having dinner, and it’s been a few days since we last had sex. Our bodies almost magnetically came together, and before long, we were naked on the couch. I was eating her pussy while simultaneously fingering her, and her moaning was very loud. She put her hand on my head and started to pull my hair, moving my face around her wet vagina. Pat was freaky.

I stood over Pat’s chest to let her suck on my dick while laying down. I was well endowed, and I think Pat liked that. She sucked on my dick like a lollipop, playing with her tongue and simultaneously jerking me off. She knew how to hit the jackpot when pleasing me. I sat down on the sofa and commanded her to sit on my dick. She sat on reverse, and did a reverse cowgirl, riding me like a champion.

I penetrated her good and hard, eventually making her gush. Then we stood up, went towards the wall, and I held her against it. I started fucking her in the ass, her moaning becoming even louder. “You like it up the ass don’t you?” I whispered in a rather angry tone into her ear as I fucked her. She moaned in pleasure. We continued to fuck, and after a few minutes someone rang the doorbell. We got dressed up quickly and cleaned off the sweat from our faces, then went to see who was at the door.

It was Lucy, and she was crying. We let her into the apartment and she seemed to be quite bad. “What happened? Why are you crying?” Pat asked her in a worried tone. “It’s Hector, I found him cheating on me with some girl… I can’t believe it” she continued crying after that. “He’s a dumbass and obviously does not deserve you, Lucy” Pat said, trying to comfort her. I really did not know what to say. “I’m sorry you had to experience this, Lucy” I said, trying to comfort her a bit more. She stopped crying and sat down, head looking down.

“I know, I’m going to go and get some junk food so we can watch a movie here together!” Pat said in a loud voice. Lucy just barely smiled, and I nodded. “You stay here with her, Jonathan. I’ll go to the supermarket, it will be super-fast”. I gave Pat my wallet then walked with her to the door. “Be careful, Lucy is a mess when she breaks up with her boyfriends. Just try to keep her from crying” she said before leaving. “I’ll do what I can” I said confidently, closing the door behind her. She was gone, and I went to sit next to Lucy.

“Pat is lucky to have you” she said, and I stayed silent. “Even after I saw him fucking that girl, Hector said that it was not what I thought it was. What else could it be?” she said, letting out a tear. “Woah. That is very mean of him. He is an ass” I said, patting her back. “So, what movies do you like?” I said, trying to deviate the topic from Hector, following Pat’s advice to not let her cry. She giggled. “I like horror movies” she said with a smile.

“I think we have some…” I said, and before being able to finish my sentence, she kissed me. I pushed her back in shock. “What are you doing?!” I said in shock. “Come on Jonathan” she said, grabbing my crotch. She did not seem sad anymore. “I thought you were sad” I said, while she massaged my crotch to get me hard. “I am. Don’t you want to help me?” She took her shirt off, to reveal she was not wearing a bra. “Of course, but this is not the way. Pat is your friend” I said in a serious tone. She unzipped my jeans and took my cock out. “You do not seem to resist, anyway. Let’s be quick”. I was at a loss at what to do, so I gave in.

I took my clothes off and decided to continue what I was doing with Pat before being interrupted by a crying Lucy. She began to suck my cock, and we avoided kissing. She stood up, and I held her against the wall, fucking her in the ass. “Fuck me just like you fuck Pat!” She yelled, and I continued to fuck her even harder. Our bodies were very sweaty now, and the thrill of Pat coming in any minute kept me alert.

I threw Lucy over the carpet, and she spread her legs before me. I dove my face into her pussy, eating it good and fingering it as well. “Fuck yeah!” she moaned. This was a completely different Lucy I had not met before. I laid over her, and started to fuck her pussy. She was moaning loudly, and I was afraid Pat would hear her from outside the apartment. I, however, continued to fuck her without giving much care. Lucy’s pussy felt warmer and wetter than Pat’s.

“Bet your boyfriend did not fuck you like this” I whispered into her ear while fucking her. “Who needs that loser” she said, then stopping to gush and moan. She had left the carpet quite wet. We could worry about that later. I continued to fuck her, then when I was about to come I took my penis out of her pussy and jerked off over her tits. I came over her the load I was going to lay on Pat. My cum was all over her tits, sliding down onto the carpet.

We stood up “we left a mess” I said, panting. “Let’s clean before Pat comes, we do not want two break ups in a single night” she said, then giggled. She went to the bathroom to clean herself, and I tried to dry the carpet with a hair dryer. It was not wet anymore, but you could see the spots on it.

“How is the cleaning going” she said while dressing up. “We will have to tell Pat that you spilt some water over the carpet” I said, putting my clothes on. “I certainly did” said Lucy, then started to laugh. “Thanks for that” she said in a cheerful tone. I couldn’t believe how quickly her mood changed. “Let’s just keep this between you and me” I told her, adjusting my belt. “Of course” she said, then giggled.

Before long, and just in time, Pat came back to the apartment. “The line was too long!” she said in an angry tone. “But look! I got cheesecake ice cream and marshmallows!” she sounded happy now. Lucy and I stayed silent. “That’s great sweetie, it’s sure to cheer Lucy up” I said in a low voice. “Of course! It’s my favorite ice cream flavor” Lucy said, now sounding a little gloom. “You should be glad you have friends like us!” Pat added, while looking through the movies. “I sure am” Lucy said, then looked at me seductively.

I was amazed. Just minutes ago, I was fucking my girlfriend’s best friend, who just interrupted my girlfriend and me having sex because her boyfriend was cheating on her. Guess I am no better than Hector.