First Creampie Ever

My girlfriend and I had both just recently turned 18 and moved into a small apartment together. We both liked to get our drink on and it would often lead to some interesting times. That night was no exception.

We invited our friend and his girlfriend over. I had gone to school with him and he lived next door to my girl growing up. So we knew him well. He had long carried a torch for my gf, to the point where it was common knowledge in the neighborhood. She never saw him in that way though. I didnt blame him one bit for wanting her. She was petite, small tits, a friggin ass to die for. She was a very flirtatious pixie like young woman.

So him and his girl come over, they brought some sort of alcohol. Being 18 we pretty much drank whatever we could get our hands on. His girl was cute. Kind of plain, a little quiet, nice body though. So we sit around, drinking, shooting the shit, then someone suggested truth or dare. We all quickly agreed.

There were some lame ideas to start. Truths are boring lol. But the dares were getting interesting. We dared the girls to show us their tits and they did. Neither of them had very big breasts, but they were pert and both had pretty pink nipples. They dared us to show our cocks so we did. Our friend had a full erection when he pulled his out. He was liking this game lol. Then I dared the girls to touch each others tits. My girl was eager to do so, she was very bi curious. She grabbed and massaged the other girls small tits, pinching her nipples too. The other girl was not as eager, but made my girl moan when she rubbed her tits.

Then the girls dared us to touch each other’s cocks. I wasn’t sure about it, but the girls said fair was fair, they touched each other. I swallowed hard and said fine. My buddy and i were on our knees facing each other. His cock was stiff and bobbing with his pulse. I was half hard myself. He reached out and grabbed my cock. He took a firm hold and stroked it a few times. Then he let go. Not wanting to be a pussy, I grabbed his. He was very hard and leaking. I could feel him trembling. I thought he was going to blow his load right there. But he didn’t. We drank some more and had some lame dares and truths. Then he dared the girls to suck each other’s breasts. They were both pretty drunk at this point and they both scked each others little tits nicely. They even threw in a little tongue kiss at the end. Ok, I was hard now lmao.

We took a break and drank some more, by this time we were all naked. They were cuddled in an arm chair my girl and I on the couch. They were whispering and giggling to each other. My girl was playing with my cock under a blanket she threw over our laps. Then our friends suggested another round of truth or dare. We sat back on the floor and the friends gf dared my girl to suck our friends cock for 30 seconds. There was no hesitation as she crawled over, pushed him backwards and swallowed his cock. It wasn’t as big as mine, so she had no troubles. We counted to thirty and she was reluctant to stop. Then she dared his girl to suck my cock. She was a but shy about it, as we later found out, our friend had taken her virginity, so mine was only the second penis she had ever touched or seen, but she did an adequate job blowing me.

Then I dared the girls to kiss each others clits. The buddy’s girl went first. My girl learned back, spread her legs and bared her pussy. She was wet, very wet. She got her clit kissed, then traded places. Her kiss on the other girls clit lasted a little longer but was still brief. I knew someday I’d watch her eat pussy.

We all sat back up and the girls leaned over to whisper something to each other. They pulled apart, both nodding then my girl said fair is fair, we dare you both to kiss each others cocks. We were both hard from watching the girls. So I said fuck it, leaned over and kissed the pink spongy head of his cock. Thrmerecwas some precum and I could taste it. Both girls moaned. Then he leaned over, took hold of my cock, kissed the head, then sucked the entire head into his mouth. Wow…wasnt expecting that. Both the girls gasped!

We took another break, got some more drinks, used the bathroom. We started to cuddle on the chair and couch again. All of us were horny as hell. They were making out and he was fingering her and she was stroking him. My girl threw the blanket over my lap and disappeared underneath it to start sucking me. I think we would have ended up fucking had they not spoke up.

His girl got up to use the bathroom. That’s when he said to us, shes only ever had sex with one guy, she would like to try swapping with you guys if you are ok with that. My girl immediately said yes, grabbed his hand and took him into the bedroom. I watched as they laid on the bed and started attacking each other. His girl came out of the bathroom, walked over to me smiling and sat in my lap. We started making out and watching them in the bedroom. We moved to the floor, positioning ourselves so we could still watch. Her bf moved between my girls thighs and we saw her reach down to guide his cock into her. I went down on his girl and licked her until she came.

By this time our buddy was fucking the shit out of my girl. I figured it was about time I got some of his girls relatively unused pussy. She was wet and spread her legs for me and pulled me close. I pushed…the head went in. I pushed again, the head went in. I was puzzled…ONLY the head of my cock would go in. She was soaked…she wanted my bigger cock…she even whispered to me that I was much bigger than him and she wanted to feel me. But no matter how we tried, I couldnt get in her tiny pussy. We laid next to each other kissing, cuddling, and watched our partners fucking through the open door. Man I wish I had been able to get in her little hairy pussy.

We watched as her boyfriend let out a yell and filled my girls pussy with his cum. We had no condoms and she was on the pill, so she let him go bare and begged him to cum in her. I can still hear her telling him, no, it’s ok, please cum in me, please. And he did. No sooner than he finished, he rolled off and came out to where I was with his girl. I got up and went to my girl in the bedroom. As I laid next to her, she pulled me on top of her. She asked me if i saw her, if I watched her get fucked. I said I did. I asked if it felt good. She said yes, but she wanted me in her. So I pushed my fat cock in her. She was soaked with his jizz. I slid right in with no resistance. I had never felt anything so wet and creamy around my cock. I pounded her as I reclaimed her. She screamed as she came on my cock and I reared back and emptied my balls onto her already overflowing pussy. Two loads in ten minutes. Then we held each other as my girl fingered herself and we watched our friends fucking in the livingroom. I’m glad he could get his cock into her tight fucking pussy!

They fucked until he came in her too. Then I had an idea. I had slipped right in my girl with his cum lubing her for me. I figured the same would happen with his girl. I walked out onto the livingroom and shard if u might try again. She eagerly nodded her head without even asking him so I moved between her soft, smooth teenaged thighs and pushed. The head popped in…I pulled back and pushed again…this time another inch. Already i had more in her than our first try. I pulled back and pushed forward again and the rest of my cock slid into her. She let out a deep moan. Her legs wrapped around my waist and we started to slowly fuck.

Her bf was holding her as we fucked. I could see him watching my cock sliding in and out of her. She had an almost painful expression on her face but kept whispering yes, yes, fuck me as she fucked me back. He played with her tits and kissed her neck as we fucked. I looked back towards the bedroom and there was my girl rubbing her pussy and fucking herself with her vibrator. She was cumming every couple minutes. Fuck she was so hot.

Then my buddy’s girl tensed up…her body stiffened, her legs fucking locked around me, she thrust her pelvis at me at screamed fuck me, I’m cumming! I felt her pussy squeeze my cock while simultaneously trying to eject me. She stopped breathing, started trembling and convulsed as she came on me. I was pushing back against her muscles that were trying to push me out and that did it. I was going to cum. Just as her boyfriend said pull out, dont cum in her, she looked at me, grabbed my ass and said fuck that, give me your cum. So, I did as the lady asked. I pushed as deep as I could go in that little bitch. I felt the head of my cock bump up against her cervix, and i came. She said omg I can feel it cum in me!!! And cum I did. I shot at least 6 times in her tiny cunt. I filled her up to over flowing.

I stayed where i was until my cock was soft. Her pussy kept spasming around me. Then I kissed her and went back to my girl. As she drifted off to sleep she said that was the hottest thing I’ve ever seen. I had to agree, it was definitely the hottest night of our young lives.