Sister-in-law

I still think of this fantasy even if it the scenario happened 12+ years ago

Since my wife and I started dating, I have had a thing for her older sister. She is only a year and half older, and looks a lot like my wife. Both have dark hair, mom bods, about 5’8.

My SIL, we’ll call her Sara, dresses like a mom, loose jeans, layered tops that fit loose. She looks nice, but not showing off.

I know her and my wife talk about each other’s sex lives. My wife, Jamie, has mentioned my BIL is hung and Sara has said it hurts sometimes. I am not hung, but we’ll proportioned, about 5 inches hard. My wife likes it and my fingers, they reach her spot perfectly. She has told her sister this over the years.

Jamie and I had been married about 5 years when Sara and her 2 boys came to visit family for the summer, they lived in Texas and us in Minnesota. Sara hadn’t met our 2nd son yet so her second day in town she came over to meet him, fortunately for me it was nap time. Jamie was at work for a couple more hours and the boys would be down for about an hour. Sara and I sat on the couch and started chatting. Sara was looking nice, loose shirt and her jeans. When she bent over to scratch her foot, her shirt opened up giving me a full view of her breasts in her bra. I stared for as long as I could, trying to see some nips or anything.

As I looked up Sara is looking at my with a slight grin, “get a good view?”

“Not as good as I’d have liked,” I responded.

“Well, here” as she lifts her shirt and bra, dropping her size D mom boobs out. Her dark nipples hard and looking great. My cock was already half hard in my shorts, now fully erect. As Sara pulled her shirt over her head, I move over on the couch and grab each tit with each hand. She gasps and looks straight in my eyes and smiles. She takes of her bra and I massage her tits and rub her nipples. She leans back on the couch as I start sucking on her left nipple, switching to her right. Sara starts to moan slightly as she runs her hands through my hair. We make eye contact as suck and pull on her left nipple. I move up and we kiss, tounges seeking each other out. Her right hand moves from my neck to my cock, rubbing it through my shorts.